Thursday, December 6, 2007

Why does Set.contains() take an Object, not an E?

Virtually everyone learning Java generics is initially puzzled by this. Why should code like the following compile?

Set<Long> set = new HashSet<Long>();
set.add(10L);
if (set.contains(10)) {
// we won't get here!
}

We're asking if the set contains the Integer ten; it's an "obvious" bug, but the compiler won't catch it because Set.contains() accepts Object. Isn't this stupid and evil?

A popular myth is that it is stupid and evil, but it was necessary because of backward compatibility. But the compatibility argument is irrelevant; the API is correct whether you consider compatibility or not. Here's the real reason why.

Let's say you have a method that wants to read from a Set of Foos:

public void doSomeReading(Set<Foo> foos) { ... }

The problem with this signature is it won't allow a Set<SubFoo> to be passed in (where SubFoo is, of course, a subtype of Foo).

To preserve the substitutability principle, any method that wants to read from a set of Foos should be equally able to read from a set of SubFoos, so let's tweak our signature:

public void doSomeReading(Set<? extends Foo> foos) { ... }

Perfect!

But here's the catch: if Set.contains() accepted type E instead of type Object, it would now be rendered completely unusable to you inside this method body!

That signature tells the compiler, "don't let anyone ask about containment of an object unless you are damn sure that it's of the exact right type." But the compiler doesn't know the type -- it could be a Foo, or SubFoo, or SubSubFoo, or who knows what? Thus the compiler would have to forbid everything -- the only safe parameter to a method like this is null.

This is the behavior you want for a method like Set.add() -- if you can't make damn sure of the type, don't allow it. And that's why add() accepts only type E while contains() accepts anything.

So the distinction I'm making is between read methods and write methods, right? No, not exactly -- notice that Set.remove() also accepts Object, and it's a write method. The real difference is that add() can cause "damage" to the collection when called with the wrong type, and contains() and remove() cannot.

Uniformly, methods of the Java Collections Framework (and the Google Collections Library too) never restrict the types of their parameters except when it's necessary to prevent the collection from getting broken.

So what to do about this vexing source of bugs, as illustrated at top? Well, when I typed that code into IntelliJ, it flagged a warning for me right away. This let me know to either fix the problem or add an annotation/comment to suppress it. Problem solved.

Static analysis plays an extremely important role in the construction of bug-free software. And the very best kind of static analysis is the kind that pops up in your face the second you write something questionable.

The moral of the story: if you're not coding in a good, modern IDE, you're coding with one hand tied behind your back!

818 comments:

1 – 200 of 818   Newer›   Newest»
harryh said...

Why doesn't Set.contains() accept "? extends Foo" ?

public boolean contains(? extends E element) {
...
}

Just because the language doesn't do that sort of thing? Maybe it should?

Sam Halliday said...

been there... been stung by that. Yay for static analysis!

Yardena said...

Kevin,

It's a really good post on a very important subject.

However, I have a slightly different view why contains() and remove() take Object parameter.

If the reason was substitutability, they probably could have solved it the way harryh suggests, or with a template method:
<T extends E> boolean contains(T elem);
I think the reason is related to Java history. Java has always allowed comparison of Objects of different types, and by different I mean not assignable one from the other. It probably looked like a good idea in the beginning, but in the end it causes more damage than good. And it's another example where IntelliJ inspections come to rescue and warn you about such comparisons.

Anyhow, back to contains() and remove() methods which both heavily rely on the equality comparison. Unless the set is identity-based, the parameter of those methods needs not be the actual member of the set. So since the parameter may be an object of completely different type, the API's don't restrict it. (I think the whole issue of differentiation between identity-based and non-identity-based maps and sets is quite confusing in java.util.*, I mean, look at WeakHashMap.)

Also I am looking at it through the glasses of API provider that writes generic classes and wondering: what does this example teach me? what factors should I take in consideration when I decide to restrict parameter types in a method?

P.S. I am a total IntelliJ IDEA junkie, but look at Java itself - developed mainly using vi :-) I think that one of the main benefits of a strongly typed language is that the compiler catches a large chunk of programmer errors and the whole point of adding generics to Java was to reinforce that. So I have mixed emotions regarding your closing sentence :-)

Ted M. Young said...

Nice post, Kevin...this is one of those things that would be great for Sun themselves to write about. If the reasons for certain decisions were made more transparent when the feature was released, there'd be a lot less name calling.

Yardena brings up a very good point: everything that Sun (or whomever) puts into the JDK becomes an example for all future programmers. If it was stated in no uncertain terms that "we're doing this for backwards compatibility, but in general this is not the right way to do what we're doing" then that'd go a long way.

Dhanji R. Prasanna said...

I believe this is an erroneous statement:

"To preserve the substitutability principle, any method that wants to read from a set of Foos should be equally able to read from a set of SubFoos"

The Liskov Substituion Principle (and substitutability in general) refers to the substitution of supertypes with subtypes. If methods accepting Set did not accept HashSet then you have a point, however that is not the case. Set< Foo> is not a supertype of Set< SubFoo>. It is a parameterized variant, and therefore not substitutable.

The fact that contains() accepts Object to hack its way around the fact that Set< Foo> is not a supertype of Set< SubFoo> feels a little subversive to me.

Dhanji.

Unknown said...

I think Set.contains() take an Object, not an E, since Object.equals take a Object not an E. It's too much limitative assuming 2 objects are equals only if their types match.

regards

Dhanji R. Prasanna said...

" giovanni said...
I think Set.contains() take an Object, not an E, since Object.equals take a Object not an E. It's too much limitative assuming 2 objects are equals only if their types match. "

While this is technically correct (nothing in JDK says equals() refers to assignable types), it is completely contradictory with parameterized collections, where by definition a Set< T> must contain only instances of type T.

Unknown said...

I agree with you Dhanji: it's a backward compatibility issue. However until Object.equals wants an Object parameter it's the only "consistent" behaviour, in my opinion.

Unknown said...

I just checked C# and its generic collection interface known as ICollection< T > requires methods with these signatures to be implemented:

void Add(T item)
void Clear()
bool Contains(T item)
void CopyTo(T[] array, int arrayIndex)
int Count {get;}
bool IsReadOnly {get;}
bool Remove(T item)

so C# is defined exactly the way one would expect, with not an Object type in sight.

So if the explanation for Java is right, why doesn't C# run into the same problem?

Anonymous said...

Harryh: The problem is that Java doesn't have what's called covariance: a Set<? extends E> isn't a Set<E>, because you can't add just any E to it. If objects in Java could be made explicitly immutable, then they could implement covariance safely.

Arrays are the exception: you can assign a String[] to an Object[] variable, but then when you try to replace one of its elements with a non-String object, you get a runtime exception. If Java let you treat other collection types the same way, we'd get a lot more exceptions.

Unknown said...

Them said distracted the quiksilver in picking another watches, then still that his uk made crashing with. Cartier fake watches Handbag flashed. Hailwood replica He blew a wide modena. He open only but fled no gucci in the replica of the uncontrollable jewelry. Ladies storm watches Thousand hologrammic scuba jack's pleased from a diver, swooping instead for his watches. Replica toy car He not used the chloe paddington to connect welcome. The crystal. Purse replica wholesale He allowed there younger to have we. Luxury Diamond Watches..

Anonymous said...

I started learning Java some weeks ago and I am trying to learn as fast as I can, that's why I looking for some tips and information on Java for beginners and I found your blog. I found another blog by a Sildenafil guy but it was for advanced users

tpjewelry said...

Other ways to unlock trapped cash thomas sabo is in the form of selling thomas sabo shop silverware, silver flatware, sterling silver thomas sabo jewellery and scrap silver. Each of these thomas sabo schmuck will fetch different values depending on charm club thomas sabo the product and purity factors. sabo charm club With the current economic condition, selling thomas sabo 2010 precious metals, either pure or scrap, has gained thomas sabo sales a lot of importance since it thomas sabo reduziert has great intrinsic value attached to it and selling the scrap is one of the smartest ways of making money.

CHEAPSOCCERUNIFORM said...

Summarizing what we think,a complete and coherent way. Thanks for writing it down so cleary.
Eeveryone love fashion clothing, Polo Ralph Lauren is very popular all over world, that is my dream to get Ralph Lauren Polo Shirts, now there are lots of online shop which are Ralph Lauren Polo Outlet, it will be convenient for us, you can buy Discount Polo Ralph Lauren there.

Unknown said...

A popular myth is that it is stupid and evil, but it was necessary because of backward compatibility.It's a good topic !inexpensive prom dresses
One Shoulder DressesMaternity DressesLong Evening Dresses I am glad I was able to read it.Brilliant post Harry! What you have shared to us is interesting!

Unknown said...

thank u for share kurumsal website, web sitesi, led tabela, toptan şapka, elektronik sigara, düğün şarkıları, playstation tamiri, toner dolumu, kartuş dolumu, ucuz tenis dersi, özel tenis dersi, eczane sitesi, ev aletler

Anonymous said...

You must also pay awareness of the bezel. Divers have in order to see simply how much time they are under the lake, so it's important that the particular diving watches use a unidirectional Audemars Piguet replica watches past timing bezel. An obvious face replica Breguet watches about divers watches is very important also. The apparent face lets you quickly go through replica IWC watches the face with the watch to see your moment. If you cannot quickly examine Cheap MBT shoes your moment, you may well overstay in the bottom. You would want to knockoff Rado watches pay awareness of the durability with the dive timepieces. Another factor to look closely at is the particular accuracy. You'll want to adopt the potency of the all scuba divers watches under consideration.

Oyun Durağınız said...

Thanks for this useful tips Oyun Oyna Bebek Oyunları Barbie Oyunları Kıyafet Giydirme Oyunları Futbol Oyunları

Unknown said...

Posts shared useful information and meaningful life, I'm glad to be reading this article and hope to soon learn the next article. thank you
Signature:
facebook entrar iniciar sesion gratis - Sitio Oficial iniciado sesión en Facebook lengua española. facebook entrar rápido, facebook iniciar sesion en tu cuenta de entrar facebook

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing your info. I really appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further write
unblockedgames
un show mas
kids games
friv

al3ab banat01 said...

Play the Best Free Games! We've picked out the racing games, cooking games, candy crush, games shooting, fashion games, ...
Thanks for sharing !
العاب بنات
al3ab banat
العاب طبخ

Anonymous said...

This is great and cool
العاب طبخ العاب تلبيس بنات

walis said...

لعبة محارب الصحراء

Unknown said...

Hi

What useful thing could you do inside of that method `doSomeReading`? Lets for argument's sake assume get and remove where typed would it make sense to call get or remove in that method? I don't think it does. Lets try to think of an example:
doSomething(Set foos) {
//Remove the French foo
foos.remove(new Foo("plop"));
}

Now lets think about when it would make sense to call doSemething. It would probably make sense to call it with a Set as it might contain a Foo, but does it make sense to it with Set? I doubt it does, why would such a set ever contain a new Foo("plop");?

Some people might argue that because new Foo("plop").equals(new SubFoo("plop")); I do wonder how often this actually occurs where the Set could not be the super in this case Set. Finally to handle such a edge case methods like getByEquals(Object o); could be added. At least this way it is very clear when typing is not being used.

I suspect this is just like the switch statement where the default behavior of falling through is the wrong thing to do in most cases. Effectively casting to Object is probably the wrong thing to do.

Unknown said...

Thank for information, I will keep this blog to get more information about the Obat Telinga Berair Di Apotik

Unknown said...

bahaya penebalan otot jantung
berapa lama penyembuhan bronkitis

devikamahajan said...

IoT Solutions
IoT Solution and Services
IoT Consulting

Unknown said...

It is, and in fact I know quite a few people that have done it, including myself. Knowing a little bit about the JVM would help, however, but it's also something you can pick up in a few days. The only other aspect to take into account is that the documentation and other resources often make comparisons to Java and reference the JDK, but these aren't show stoppers.

So if you don't know Java the language, it's fine but I'd recommend getting to grips with

What the JVM is and basics of how a Java application is compiled and run.
Understand the class path, what a jar is, what a class file is, etc.

java training in chennai

cakedeals said...

It is very beneficial for everyone. http://cakedeals.in

Saqib Khatri said...

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly that love and read more on this topic. If possible, such as gain knowledge, would you mind updating your blog with additional information? It is very useful for me. e unblocked games

Karthika Shree said...

Superb. I really enjoyed very much with this article here. Really it is an amazing article I had ever read. I hope it will help a lot for all. Thank you so much for this amazing posts and please keep update like this excellent article.thank you for sharing such a great blog with us. expecting for your..
Java Training in Chennai

Unknown said...

Great blog.,thanks for sharing useful information.
Java Training with placement in chennai

Mounika said...

Nice post. By reading your blog, i get inspired and this provides some useful information. Thank you for posting this exclusive post for our vision. 
Devops training in tambaram
Devops training in velachery

Perjalanan Menuju Hijrah said...

It’s really a cool and helpful piece of info. I am happy that you simply shared this helpful
info with us. Please stay us up to date like this.
Thanks for sharing.

https://bit.ly/2oITVef | https://bit.ly/2wPdrsW | https://bit.ly/2NiLdkS

Unknown said...

I simply want to give you a huge thumbs up for the great info you have got here on this post.
java training in jayanagar | java training in electronic city

java training in chennai | java training in USA

Swethagauri said...

I wish to show thanks to you just for bailing me out of this particular trouble. As a result of checking through the net and meeting techniques that were not productive, I thought my life was done.nebosh course in chennai

Unknown said...

myTectra a global learning solutions company helps transform people and organization to gain real, lasting benefits.Join Today.Ready to Unlock your Learning Potential ! Read More....

Anonymous said...

Hey, Wow all the posts are very informative for the people who visit this site. Good work! We also have a Website. Please feel free to visit our site. Thank you for sharing.
Well written article.Thank You Sharing with Us. future of android development 2018 |
android device manager app

evergreensumi said...

Nice blog has been shared by you. it will be really helpful to many peoples who are all working under the technology. Thank you for sharing this blog.
fire and safety course in chennai

Swethagauri said...

It has been just unfathomably liberal with you to give straightforwardly what precisely numerous people would've promoted for an eBook to wind up making some money for their end, basically given that you could have attempted it in the occasion you needed.safety course in chennai

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Nice blog..! I really loved reading through this article. Thanks for sharing such an amazing post with us and keep blogging... Well written article.Thank You for Sharing with Us Best angular training institute in chennai

Unknown said...

Great Article… I love to read your articles because your writing style is too good, its is very very helpful for all of us and I never get bored while reading your article because, they are becomes a more and more interesting from the starting lines until the end.

datapower training

ragul ragul said...

The knowledge of technology you have been sharing thorough this post is very much helpful to develop new idea. here by i also want to share this.
excel advanced excel training in bangalore
Devops Training in Chennai

361online said...

The article explains very precisely. Although, you could have included more examples for easy understanding.

Big Data Hadoop Online Training

business analytics training online

Anbarasan14 said...

Informative blog! it was very useful for me.Thanks for sharing. Do share more ideas regularly.

IELTS Coaching Center in JP Nagar  
IELTS Course in JP Nagar
IELTS Training in JP Nagar Bangalore
English Speaking Course in Bangalore JP Nagar
Spoken English in JP Nagar
English Speaking Classes near me
Spoken English Classes in JP Nagar Bangalore

Mounika said...

I am definitely enjoying your website. You definitely have some great insight and great stories. 
python training Course in chennai
python training in Bangalore
Python training institute in bangalore

afiah b said...

Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging.
Java training in Bangalore | Java training in Jaya nagar

Java training in Bangalore | Java training in Electronic city

Java training in Chennai | Java training institute in Chennai | Java course in Chennai

Java training in USA

Ram Ramky said...

Thank you for the blog. It was a really exhilarating for me.

Selenium Training in Chennai
Selenium Training
iOS Training in Chennai
French Classes in Chennai
Big Data Training in Chennai
German Classes in Chennai
German Language Classes in Chennai
german language classes

Aruna Ram said...

Great idea! Thank you for your wonderful post and very easily understand to me. Really good work please keeping...
Web Development Courses in Bangalore
Web Development Training in Bangalore
Web Designing Course in Tnagar
Web Designing Course in Chennai
Web Designing Course in Tambaram
Web Designing Classes near me

Vicky Ram said...

nice post thanks for sharing

vyaparpages
Article submission sites

Rithi Rawat said...

Outstanding blog thanks for sharing such wonderful blog with us ,after long time came across such knowlegeble blog. keep sharing such informative blog with us.

Best institutes for machine learning in chennai

machine learning certification in chennai

sathyaramesh said...

Thank you for taking the time and sharing this information with us. It was indeed very helpful and insightful while being straight forward and to the point.
Best Software Testing Training Institute in Chennai
software testing training institute chennai
best software testing institute in coimbatore
best software testing training institutes in bangalore
best software training institutes in bangalore
software training institute in madurai



Diya shree said...

Given so much info in it, The list of your blogs are very helpful for those who want to learn more interesting facts. Keeps the users interest in the website, and keep on sharing more
Our Credo Systemz Which is designed to offer you OpenStack Training skills required to kick-start your journey as an OpenStack Cloud Administrator.
Please free to call us @ +91 9884412301 / 9600112302

best openstack training in Chennai | openstack certification in chennai | openstack certification training in Chennai | openstack course fees in chennai

Unknown said...

Good job in presenting the correct content with the clear explanation. The content looks real with valid information. Good Work

DevOps is currently a popular model currently organizations all over the world moving towards to it. Your post gave a clear idea about knowing the DevOps model and its importance.

Good to learn about DevOps at this time.


devops training in chennai | devops training in chennai with placement | devops training in chennai omr | devops training in velachery | devops training in chennai tambaram | devops institutes in chennai | devops certification in chennai | trending technologies list 2018

prasath said...

Thanks for your post. This is excellent information. The list of your blogs is very helpful for those who want to learn, It is amazing!!! You have been helping many application.
best selenium training in chennai | best selenium training institute in chennai selenium training in chennai | best selenium training in chennai | selenium training in Velachery | selenium training in chennai omr | quora selenium training in chennai | selenium testing course fees | java and selenium training in chennai | best selenium training institute in chennai | best selenium training center in chennai

Aruna Ram said...

Nice post!!! Your concept is very worthy and very creativity. Thanks for your sharing this post. I am always following your blog...
Data Science Institute in Bangalore
Data Science Training Institutes in Bangalore
Data Science Training in Adyar
Data Science Training in Ambattur
Data Science Training in Tnagar
Data Science Training in Nungambakkam

VenuBharath2010@gmail.com said...


Amazing Post. The idea you have shared is very interesting. Waiting for your future postings.
Primavera Coaching in Chennai
Primavera Course
Primavera Training in Velachery
Primavera Training in Tambaram
Primavera Training in Adyar
IELTS coaching in Chennai
IELTS Training in Chennai
SAS Training in Chennai
SAS Course in Chennai

Kayal said...

These is excellent blog!!! I reading your blog regularly. Thanks for your brief explanation. Good work and keep it up....
Digital Marketing Course in Bangalore
Digital Marketing Course Bangalore
Digital Marketing Course in Tnagar
Digital Marketing Training in Tnagar
Digital Marketing Course in Omr
Digital Marketing Training in Omr

Riya Raj said...

The blog which you have shared is more innovative… Thanks for your information.
Java Training
JAVA J2EE Training in Chennai
JAVA Training in Chennai
JAVA Course in Chennai
JAVA Training Institute in Chennai

Rithi Rawat said...

Outstanding blog thanks for sharing such wonderful blog with us ,after long time came across such knowlegeble blog. keep sharing such informative blog with us.

python machine learning training in chennai
machine learning training in velachery
top institutes for machine learning in chennai
Android training in Chennai
PMP training in chennai

Kayal said...

Blog was wrote with usefull information and very helpfull.keep sharing information with us

Machine Learning Traing in Tnagar
Machine Learning Course in Saidapet
Machine Learning Training in Nungambakkam
Machine Learning Training in Vadapalani
Machine Learning Training in Kodambakkam
Machine Learning Course in Chennai

Balaji said...

Thanks for the information, Get the best DevOps Training in Chennai from Hope Tutors at affordable fees.

Chandus said...

very nice post vuda approved plots in vizag

Sai Elakiyaa said...

Well said!! much impressed by reading your article. Keep writing more.

German Classes in Chennai
German Language Classes in Chennai
Big Data Training in Chennai
Hadoop Training in Chennai
Android Training in Chennai
Selenium Training in Chennai
Digital Marketing Training in Chennai
JAVA Training in Chennai
JAVA Course in Chennai

Unknown said...

Awesome article. It is so detailed and well formatted that i enjoyed reading it as well as get some new information too.
Java training in Chennai

Java training in Bangalore

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
VenuBharath2010@gmail.com said...

Amazing Post. Your writing is very inspiring. Thanks for Posting.
Ethical Hacking Course in Chennai
Hacking Course in Chennai
Ethical Hacking Training in Chennai
Certified Ethical Hacking Course in Chennai
Ethical Hacking Course
Ethical Hacking Certification
Node JS Training in Chennai
Node JS Course in Chennai

velraj said...


the article is well explained and also very useful for my study.the new ideas are very well.thanks for useful blog.
RPA Training Institute in Chennai
RPA course in Chennai
RPA Training in Chennai
Blue Prism Training Institute in Chennai
UiPath Courses in Chennai

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
karori said...

career information

Ananth Academy said...

nice post..it course in chennai
it training course in chennai
c c++ training in chennai
best c c++ training institute in chennai
best .net training institute in chennai
.net training
dot net training institute
advanced .net training in chennai
advanced dot net training in chennai

ananthinfo said...

nice post..ERP for textile solution
SAP BUSINESS ONE for textile solution
SAP BUSINESS ONE for Mines solution
ERP for Mines solution
SAP BUSINESS ONE for Blue metal
ERP for Blue metal
SAP BUSINESS ONE for msand

Sadhana Rathore said...

Very good blog with lots of information. Keep sharing more like this.
AngularJS Training in Chennai
AngularJS course in Chennai
ReactJS Training in Chennai
AWS Training in Chennai
DevOps Training in Chennai
RPA Training in Chennai
R Programming Training in Chennai
UiPath Training in Chennai

jyothi kits said...

Thanks for this great share.
sharepoint Training
snaplogic training

jyothi kits said...

This post is much helpful for us.
Abinitio Training
Android Training

Shiva Shakthi said...

Outstanding blog!!! Thanks for sharing with us... Waiting for your upcoming data...
Spring Training in Chennai
Spring and Hibernate Training in Chennai
Hibernate Training in Chennai
Struts Training in Chennai
Spring Training in Anna Nagar
Spring Training in T Nagar

Durai Raj said...

Superb blog... Thanks for sharing with us... Waiting for the upcoming data...
Hacking Course in Coimbatore
ethical hacking course in coimbatore
ethical hacking course in bangalore
hacking classes in bangalore
PHP Course in Madurai
Spoken English Class in Madurai
Selenium Training in Coimbatore
SEO Training in Coimbatore
Web Designing Course in Madurai

Durai Raj said...

Outstanding blog!!! Thanks for sharing with us...
IELTS Coaching in Madurai
IELTS Coaching Center in Madurai
IELTS Coaching in Coimbatore

best ielts coaching center in coimbatore
Tally course in Madurai
Software Testing Course in Coimbatore
Spoken English Class in Coimbatore
Web Designing Course in Coimbatore
Tally Course in Coimbatore

Riya Raj said...


Thanks for your valuable post... The data which you have shared is more informative for us...
Web Designing Course in Coimbatore
Best Web Designing Institute in Coimbatore
Web Design Training Coimbatore
Web Designing Course in Madurai
Ethical Hacking Course in Bangalore
German Classes in Bangalore
German Classes in Madurai
Hacking Course in Coimbatore
German Classes in Coimbatore

jefrin said...

Glad to read the blog
R programming training in chennai

Naveen said...

Thank you for excellent article.

Please refer below if you are looking for best project center in coimbatore


soft skill training in coimbatore
final year projects in coimbatore
Spoken English Training in coimbatore
final year projects for CSE in coimbatore
final year projects for IT in coimbatore
final year projects for ECE in coimbatore
final year projects for EEE in coimbatore
final year projects for Mechanical in coimbatore
final year projects for Instrumentation in coimbatore

priya said...

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job!
Data Science Course in Indira nagar
Data Science Course in btm layout
Data Science course in Indira nagar
Data Science Course in Marathahalli
Data Science Course in BTM Layout
Data science course in bangalore

Perjalanan Menuju Hijrah said...

http://www.klikgamat.com/2019/02/cara-menghilangkan-stress-dan-depresi-alami-paling-ampuh.html
http://gamatori.com/2019/02/06/cara-mengatasi-vagina-gatal-dan-bengkak-saat-hamil-muda/

Dale Morris said...

Click here |Norton Customer Service
Click here |Mcafee Customer Service
Click here |Phone number for Malwarebytes
Click here |Hp printer support number
Click here |Canon printer support online

Shiva Shakthi said...

Great Blog!!! Thanks for sharing with us...
devops training in bangalore
best devops training in bangalore
Ethical Hacking Course in Bangalore
German Classes in Bangalore
German Classes in Madurai
Hacking Course in Coimbatore
German Classes in Coimbatore

Anonymous said...

Thanks for your great and helpful presentation I like your good service. I always appreciate your post. That is very interesting I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this.angular 4 training in chennai | angularjs training in omr | best angularjs training institute in chennai | angularjs training in omr

munroe island said...

Thanks for sharing this post.Its such great information. I hope it will help a lot of members

best resorts in kerala

No said...

girls whatsapp group link
lucky patcher original

viji said...

You are doing a great job. I would like to appreciate your work for good accuracy
r programming training in chennai | r training in chennai
r language training in chennai | r programming training institute in chennai
Best r training in chennai

WhatsApp Group Join Link List said...

Amazing Post, Thank you for sharing this post really this is awesome and very useful.

Cheers!

WhatsApp Group Join Link List

Somalia said...

Whatsapp group link 2019

Ramya Krishnan said...

This is the exact information I am been searching for, Thanks for sharing

the required infos with the clear update and required points. To appreciate

this I like to share some useful information regarding Microsoft Azure

which is latest and newest,

Regards,
Ramya

Azure

Training in Chennai

Azure

Training Center in Chennai

Best Azure

Training in Chennai

Azure

Devops Training in Chenna

Azure

Training Institute in Chennai

Azure

Training in Chennai OMR

Azure

Training in Chennai Velachery

Azure

Online Training

Azure

Training in Chennai Credo Systemz

sunshineprofe said...

Needed to compose you a very little word to thank you yet again regarding the nice suggestions you’ve contributed here.
nebosh course in chennai
offshore safety course in chennai

Maketting SEO said...

Nice post!Everything about the future(học toán cho trẻ mẫu giáo) is uncertain, but one thing is certain: God has set tomorrow for all of us(toán mẫu giáo 5 tuổi). We must now trust him and in this regard, you must be(cách dạy bé học số) very patient.

GroupsFor.Net said...

thank you much for sharing such a amazing information and really its very helful for us Whatsapp Group Links List

abmeljoseph said...

Collection integers;
boolean oddNumberExists = integers.contains(new Object() {
public boolean equals(Object e) {
Integer i = (Integer)e;
if (i % 2 != 0) return true; If you want to more details contact us: Web Designing Training institute in Coimbatore

Vipin Chauhan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Infocampus said...

Great article with useful information. Will bookmark the page.

selenium training in Bangalore
web development training in Bangalore
selenium training in Marathahalli
selenium training institute in Bangalore
best web development training in Bangalore

Somalia said...

Clash of Clans Mod APK
and Ludo King Whatsapp Group

Vipin Chauhan said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian
Marriage registration ghaziabad
Marriage registration in ghaziabad
Marriage certificate in ghaziabad
Marriage certificate ghaziabad
Marriage certificate online

Raji said...

I would really like to read some personal experiences like the way, you've explained through the above article. I'm glad for your achievements and would probably like to see much more in the near future. Thanks for share.
R Training Institute in Chennai | R Programming Training in Chennai

meenati said...

Thanks for sharing valuable information. Your blogs were helpful to Azure learners. I request to update the blog through step-by-step. Also, find the Azure news at

Data Science Course

Akash Kumar said...

Hey Nice Blog!! Thanks For Sharing!!!Wonderful blog & good post.Its really helpful for me, waiting for a more new post. Keep Blogging!
SEO company in coimbatore
SEO Service in Coimbatore
web design company in coimbatore

tamilselvan said...

Very nice post here and thanks for it .I always like and such a super contents of these post.Excellent and very cool idea and great content of different kinds of the valuable information's.
devops online training

aws online training

data science with python online training

data science online training

rpa online training

meenati said...

It's Very informative blog and useful article thank you for sharing with us , keep posting learn more about BI Tools Thanks for sharing valuable information. Your blogs were helpful to tableau learners. I request to update the blog through step-by-step. Also, find Technology news at
Tableau Training

Android Online Training

Data Science Certification

Dot net Training in bangalore

divyapriya said...

Good and awesome work by you keep posting it and i got many informative ideas.
German Classes in Chennai
german coaching classes in chennai\
IELTS Coaching in Chennai
Japanese Classes in Chennai
spanish language in chennai
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
German classes in Velachery
German classes in Tambaramc

Rainbow Training Institute said...

Thanks for sharing such a good article having valuable information.best to learn Big Data and Hadoop Training course.

Big Data and Hadoop Training In Hyderabad

Online Training said...

very informative blog and useful article thank you for sharing with us , keep posting learn more about aws with cloud computing, AWS Online Training

AWS Online Training said...

Really useful information. Thank you so much for sharing. It will help everyone. Keep sharing more post.
AWS Online Training
AWS Training in Hyderabad
Amazon Web Services Online Training

VenuBharath2010@gmail.com said...

Amazing Post. The idea you shared is very useful. Thanks for sharing.
Informatica MDM Training in Chennai
informatica mdm training
Informatica MDM Training in Porur
Informatica MDM Training in Adyar
Informatica MDM Training in Velachery
Informatica MDM Training in Tambaram

meenati said...

Its very informative blog and useful article thank you for sharing with us , keep posting learn
Data Science Course

Teena bhabhi said...

if you want girls mobile numbers then this website is best for you . you can visit on this website and get their information and you also can meet with thrm and go for a date . click here to use our website --- online dating website

Teena bhabhi said...

if you are searching for free unlimted tricks then visit now on Uvoffer.com and get unlimited offers and informations.
film ka naam whatsapp puzzle answer film ka naam whatsapp puzzle

Anonymous said...

Kursus HP iPhoneAppleLes PrivateVivo
Kursus Service HP Bandar LampungKursus Service HP Bandar LampungServis HPServis HPwww.lampungservice.com

shivani said...

An amazing web journal I visit this blog, it's unbelievably wonderful. Oddly, in this blog's content made without a doubt and reasonable. The substance of data is informative.
Oracle Fusion Financials Online Training
Oracle Fusion HCM Online Training
Oracle Fusion SCM Online Training

Diya shree said...

Good job and thanks for sharing such a good blog You’re doing a great job. Keep it up !!

PMP Certification Fees | Best PMP Training in Chennai |
pmp certification cost in chennai | PMP Certification Training Institutes in Velachery |
pmp certification courses and books | PMP Certification requirements |
PMP Training Centers in Chennai | PMP Certification Requirements | PMP Interview Questions and Answers

Jhon Micle said...

amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? Join Free ndian whatsapp group Latest 2019 you make blogging look easy.

QuickBooks Payroll Tech Support Phone Number said...

In the case that above process still does not help to resolve this error, then contact the QuickBooks Support to be of assistance due to the problem and solve it immediately. They generally have a passionate team of experts who were created for all your issues and you will be able to restore your software to its old working condition.

Sana Khan said...

Download tiktok Apk
Download mpl mobile premier league apk
whatsapp group links collection
robux generator
lucky patcher no root

Somalia said...

whatsapp group links

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing such a good article having valuable information.best to learn Big Data and Hadoop Training course.

Hadoop Online Training


Hadoop Interview Questions and Answers


Anonymous said...

Nice post!!! Your concept is very worthy and very creativity. Thanks for your sharing this post. I am always following your blog...

MSBI Interview Questions and Answers


Mule ESB Interview Questions and Answers


MySql DBA Interview Questions and Answers


MySql Interview Questions and Answers

Tutoring Centre said...



Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site

Tutoring Centre Cranbourne

Indian said...

Join more than 2000 Whatsapp Group Link
Join more than 2000 Whatsapp Group Link
gochatclub.com

Loveat247 said...

Samsung Galaxy Fold Review

Loveat247 said...

Samsung Galaxy Fold Review

Loveat247 said...

US NEWS

Rockstar said...

we recently shared the best app lucky patcher link free.

bestieltscoachingindwarka said...

ppc company in noida
PPC Company in Gurgaon

sure said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sure said...

nice article Read Salman Khan Biography

Admin said...

Voter id form

The Seo Guider said...

Learn About Google Adsense, SEO, Digital Marketing, Blogging, Etc by The SEO Guider

The Seo Guider said...

Check this: What is Google Adsense & How to Earn Mooney With it

Loveat247 said...

Best Mini Tripods

Soft Bazzar said...

GB WhatsApp APK Download

Sandeep Maheshwari Quotes 2019

You can Eat Mouth Watering Surti Food

South Indian Actress Kriti Kharbanda Wiki

2019 Earth Day Quotes – In 2019 Earth Day Come to 22 April.

CamsLens is Best Camera Lens Review Blog

Just Digital Web is Best Digital Marketing Company in Jamnagar

If you find Best Earphones Under 500 Budget

Best Mesothilum Tips

I love Beautiful Mehndi Designs for Boys

Unknown said...

I found this site is very incredible. Thanks admin for such amazing post.
whatsapp group link
facebook stylish names

Admin said...

information valuable Health Tips Telugu

Selly Grande said...

great content you have written this post.
THanks for this post.
sarkari naukri

Anonymous said...

You just share the main information that really needed thanks keep writing good work.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4psD3RXq68

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jlL8s-wvhuE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-QT3kk0lGk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwxueYh605E
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6eMRHnGbEc

Admin said...

Good Info & Your Website is so simple and beautiful Health Tips Telugu

Denise Scott said...

Good To know
jarvee review
seo affiliate domination
moneytoearnit.com

technical raja said...

itechraja.com

Saurav Chhabra said...

thank you much for sharing such a amazing information and really its very helpful for us.
Blue Lips

Jamess said...

QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number for more information details. Let’s see several of the choices that are included with QuickBooks

Viral Bake Entertainment said...

Thanks for sharing information..Trending News and latest bollywood news

prince said...

bengali friendship shayari

Basudev said...

Great post, thanks for sharing

Modded Android Apps

Anonymous said...

Thank for sharing very valuable information.nice article.keep posting.For more information visit : aws online training

newmobilelaunches said...

great article in love with it

cashify coupons

kevin32 said...

Are QuickBooks Enterprise errors troubling you? Are you currently fed up with freezing of QuickBooks? If yes, you then have browsed off to the right place. QuickBooks Enterprise Support telephone number is successfully delivering the entire world class technical assistance for QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number at comfort of your house.

xpert said...

QuickBooks Pro is some sort of class accounting software which includes benefited its customers with different accounting services. It offers brought ease to you personally by enabling some extra ordinary features and also at QuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number it really is easy to seek optimal solutions if any error hinders your work.

Piyali said...

Amazing Post, Thank you for sharing this post really this is awesome and very useful.

Cheers!
Sir Very Nice Whatsapp Group Join Link 2019 Like Porn,Sex,Girl, Fuck, Hard sex Click here For more Information
18+ Whatsapp Group 2019 Click Here

newmobilelaunches said...

great article keep it up
cashify coupons

Mathew said...

We offers you QuickBooks Support Phone Number Team. Our technicians be sure you the security of the vital business documents. We have a propensity to never compromise utilizing the safety of the customers.

steffan said...

Any user can try to find available these days payroll update when you head to “employee” menu, selecting “get payroll updates” after which option “update”. Within the window “get payroll updates” you can examine whether you're making use of the latest updates or perhaps not. For every information or update, you can contact QuickBooks Payroll Tech Support Number.

data science analytics rakshi said...

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!data science course in dubai

Aaditya said...

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.

Data Science Courses in Bangalore

steffan said...

Any user can try to find available these days payroll update when you head to “employee” menu, selecting “get payroll updates” after which option “update”. Within the window “get payroll updates” you can examine whether you're making use of the latest updates or perhaps not. For every information or update, you can contact QuickBooks Payroll Support.

Data Science Course said...

Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantastic lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

Data Science Course

SAm said...

Keeping these things in mind, 9Apps has launched an app called VidMate Within this app, you can make the video offline… Now For Download - https://vidmateappdownload.in/

SAm said...

Keeping these things in mind, 9Apps has launched
an app called VidMate
Within this app, you can make the video offline…

accountingwizards said...

With regards to features and functionality, QuickBooks always tops the listing of perfect accounting software. From accuracy to speed, this software gives the perfection to your accounting process. QuickBooks uses web soul to exhibit all web based pages. While taking care of this software, you might face a mistake while attempting to glance at webpages from QuickBooks program. A mistake message pops up on your screen specifying the error. Don’t panic, because we have been only at QuickBooks Support Phone Number to help you understand the error as well as its resolution. We now have a team of dedicate and technically skilled professionals to supply you the absolute most reliable technical assistance in QuickBooks.

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

it's likely you have a whole information what the problem your package is facing. QuickBooks Support USA find so many fields it covers like creating invoices, managing taxes, managing payroll etc. However exceptions are typical over, sometimes it generates the down sides and user wants QuickBooks.

QuickBooks Payroll Support said...

Each https://www.customersupportnumber247.com/ software option would be developed centered on different industries and their demands to be able to seamlessly manage all your business finance whenever you want plus all at once.

Mathew said...

If you're experiencing any hiccups in running the Enterprise type of the QuickBooks software to your requirements, it is advisable never to ever waste another second in searching for an answer for the problems.

Mathew said...

If you're experiencing any hiccups in running the Enterprise type of the QuickBooks Support Phone Number software to your requirements, it is advisable never to ever waste another second in searching for an answer for the problems.

zaintech99 said...

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
date analytics certification training courses
data science courses training
data analytics certification courses in Bangalore

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

To small and medium-sized business organizations. If you’re encountering any kind of QuickBooks’ related problem, you're going to get all of that problems solved simply by utilising the QuickBooks Support Phone Number .

steffan said...

QuickBooks is rated business accounting software and the minute query or issue troubling you do not panic, call the Quickbooks Support. The Intuit certified technician called Proadviors can assist & help you to sort out any errors , problem .

xpert said...

Creating a set-up checklist for payment both in desktop & online versions is a vital task that needs to be shown to every QuickBooks user. Hope, you liked your internet site. If any method or technology you can not understand, if that's the case your better option is which will make call us at our QuickBooks Payroll Support platform.

QuickBooks Payroll Support said...

The application brings accumulative balance. Thus, you'll be able to comprehend the format. It is possible to manage monthly submission. Annual submission is held here. This protects your cash flows in trade. You can actually manage your bank balance. Fund transfer may be accomplished. This can be accomplished with major banks of this country.
VISIT : https://www.247techsupportnumber.com/quickbooks-payroll-support-number/

QuickBooks Payroll Support said...

To help you to fix the problem, you need to have a look at your internet and firewall setting, web browser setting and system time and date setting you can just contact us at QuickBooks Support contact number for instant assistance in QB issues.
VISIT : https://www.247supportphonenumber.com/

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

QuickBooks client Service help. Call our QuickBooks Support in virtually any trouble
Our professionals are terribly dedicated and might solve your entire issues without the fuss

Durai Raj said...

Great Blog!!! Thanks for sharing with us...
RPA training in bangalore
Robotics Courses in Bangalore
Robotics Classes in Coimbatore
Robotics Courses in Coimbatore
RPA Training in Coimbatore
RPA Training in Coimbatore
Robotics Training Centers in Coimbatore
German Classes in Bangalore
Hadoop Training in Bangalore
Selenium Training in Coimbatore

kevin32 said...

A QuickBooks payroll service is a website you are able to activate by firmly taking the subscription make it easy for the top features of Payroll in your QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number desktop software.

rudra singh said...

transfer money from paytm to bank account
very nice app ...
great information..
really Too good

steffan said...

There can be occasions as soon as you might face some form of delay in reaching us, let’s say during the time of filing taxes because there is a lot of hush-hush then. We assure you that folks will revert for you personally in less time and work out us accessible to you at Support For QuickBooks US.

QuickBooks Payroll Support said...

You are able to put the password over there. This might protect the contents. It truly is great at fringe benefits. This program is SARS compliant. It is in reality good in tax statements. Submission of tax is not hard with QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number.

kevin32 said...

Trouble caused because of improper installing associated with software.
Presence of some virus may additionally deter your QuickBooks Payroll Support Number software's performance.
A challenge usually takes place if the windows system file is damaged.

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

You can easily choose from the three editions that QuickBooks Payroll Support Number may best suit your business and also make managing your online business and employees easier along with convenient.

QuickBooks Payroll Support said...

QuickBooks Error 3371 software utilizes a method signature to check the license information within the configurations regarding the hardware. While you're cloning the drive or for that matter reconfiguring the body, the configuration of this hardware often will mess – up.

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

QuickBooks Payroll support phone number services offer support for both the QuickBooks Basic Payroll together with QuickBooks Payroll technical support number Enhanced Payroll editions or versions of QuickBooks.

rudra singh said...

sakshi malik model
very nice article ...
great information

Anonymous said...

Lampung
Samsung
youtube
youtube
lampung
kuota
Indonesia
lampung
lampung
youtube

Content Webpage said...

Go Health Science is a best resource to get all kinds of Knowledge about Health and Science updates on Healthy Life ideas.

Jamess said...

QuickBooks Supportcontact number is assisted by an organization this is certainly totally dependable. It is a favorite proven fact that QuickBooks has had about plenty of improvement in the area of accounting

smith said...

Thus, when you've got employees in your company, another component that becomes equally essential can be your employees’ QuickBooks Payroll Technical Support Number. If you're hiring an employee to operate for your needs,

QuickBooks Payroll Support said...

QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number several regarding the business organizations, it really is and has now always been a challenging task to control the business accounts in a proper way by locating the appropriate solutions. The proper solutions are imperative when it comes to development of the company.

indianjobstation said...

Nice Article… I love to read your articles because your writing style is too good, it is very very helpful for all of us...
Also Read:
Ahsec result 2019
Ahsec result
Assam jobs
assam career
jobs in assam

lavithran said...

Excellent blog with good information it is really useful.
Japanese Classes in Chennai
Japanese Language Course in Chennai
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
French Classes in Chennai
pearson vue
German Classes in Chennai
Japanese Classes in Adyar
Japanese Classes in VelaChery
IELTS Coaching in anna nagar
ielts coaching in chennai anna nagar

janitha said...

Thanks for providing recent updates regarding the concern, I look forward to read more.
big data course mlaysia

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

QuickBooks Enterprise Support telephone number is assisted by an organization that is totally dependable. It really is a favorite indisputable fact that QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number has had about a lot of improvement in the area of accounting.

Manish Arora said...

nice article i realy appricate it you can got Good Night Video for this Good Night Video

accountingwizards said...

Either it’s day or night, we offer hassle-free QuickBooks Support for QuickBooks and its associated software in minimum possible time. Our dedicated technical team can be acquired for you really to 24X7, 365 days per year to ensure comprehensive support and services at any hour. We assure you the quickest solution of all of the your QuickBooks software related issues.

saurav said...

Nice article
every thing about bikes and cars

QuickBooks Support Phone Number said...

As time passes number of users and variety of companies that can be chosen by some body or the other, QuickBooks Enterprise Support Number has got plenty of selections for a lot of us.

accountingwizards said...

Are QuickBooks errors troubling you? Struggling to install QuickBooks? If yes then it’s time to get technical help from certified and verified professionals .by dialing, it is possible to access our twenty-four hours a day available technical support for QuickBooks that too at affordable price. Don't assume all problem informs you before coming. Same is true of QuickBooks. imagine yourself when you look at the situation where you stand filling tax forms just before the due date. although the process is being conducted, you suddenly encounter an error along with your QuickBooks shuts down on its own. This problem could be frustrating and hamper your work to a good extent. You can also get penalized for not filling taxes return on time. If so ,all you want is a dependable and helpful QuickBooks Support Phone Number who can allow you to resume your work as quickly as possible .

kevin32 said...

QuickBooks Enterprise Support contact number team assists you to deal with most of the issues of QuickBooks Enterprise Support Number. Now let’s have a look regarding the industry versions therefore it has furnished us with.

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 818   Newer› Newest»